Eugene Garver
- Published in print:
- 2012
- Published Online:
- September 2013
- ISBN:
- 9780226284026
- eISBN:
- 9780226284040
- Item type:
- chapter
- Publisher:
- University of Chicago Press
- DOI:
- 10.7208/chicago/9780226284040.003.0007
- Subject:
- Philosophy, Ancient Philosophy
This chapter offers a treatment of the city of prayer, as seen in Books VII and VIII, that turns on two textual questions, both concerning the relation between the best life and the best ...
More
This chapter offers a treatment of the city of prayer, as seen in Books VII and VIII, that turns on two textual questions, both concerning the relation between the best life and the best constitution. The textual puzzles provide access to philosophical problems. The first three chapters of Book VII are examined here in an effort to show how their complex argument entitles Aristotle to talk about a constitution as happy and virtuous without falling into circularity and the fallacy of composition. Utilizing such predicates gives Aristotle the ability to infer from the best life to the best constitution, and equally, from the best constitution to the best life. Book VII also contains three separate examinations of the best life, which is a subject of discussion here. From these three discussions of happiness, the author aims to identify exactly what can be inferred from them in constructing the best state.Less
This chapter offers a treatment of the city of prayer, as seen in Books VII and VIII, that turns on two textual questions, both concerning the relation between the best life and the best constitution. The textual puzzles provide access to philosophical problems. The first three chapters of Book VII are examined here in an effort to show how their complex argument entitles Aristotle to talk about a constitution as happy and virtuous without falling into circularity and the fallacy of composition. Utilizing such predicates gives Aristotle the ability to infer from the best life to the best constitution, and equally, from the best constitution to the best life. Book VII also contains three separate examinations of the best life, which is a subject of discussion here. From these three discussions of happiness, the author aims to identify exactly what can be inferred from them in constructing the best state.
Christopher Collard (ed.)
- Published in print:
- 2007
- Published Online:
- January 2014
- ISBN:
- 9781904675730
- eISBN:
- 9781781385364
- Item type:
- book
- Publisher:
- Liverpool University Press
- DOI:
- 10.5949/liverpool/9781904675730.001.0001
- Subject:
- Classical Studies, Literary Studies: Classical, Early, and Medieval
Twenty of the author's shorter pieces first published between 1963 and 2004 (when the book was initially prepared), which emphasize textual questions, verbal criticism, dramatic form and general ...
More
Twenty of the author's shorter pieces first published between 1963 and 2004 (when the book was initially prepared), which emphasize textual questions, verbal criticism, dramatic form and general interpretation. They are grouped roughly under the three words of the title, and handle subjects ranging from A: phenomena general to Greek Tragedy: its demand upon students and readers; stichomythia; the fragmentary tragedian Chaeremon; the attribution of a fragmentary Pirithous-play; the textual quality of quotations in Athenaeus; review of an important select edition of fragments; through (B): some topics particular to Euripides: scribal hands in a famous manuscript; the problematic Funeral Oration in Suppliants; that play's disputed date; appreciation of a choral ode in Hecuba; specialist lexicography of the poet; reviews of the now standard critical edition of the poet; to (C): appreciations of some scholars of Tragedy and particularly Euripides prominent since the 16th Century: Dirk Canter, Joshua Barnes, Jeremiah Markland, Samuel Musgrave, Peter Elmsley, James Henry Monk, and Frederick Apthorp Paley. All pieces have been edited, revised and supplemented with notes and bibliography as far as 2006. The problems of collecting and editing fragmentary texts emerge as the author's regular interest, anticipating his concentration on this work since 1995, in five collaborative editions and some shorter studies, some of which are listed or heralded in his List of Publications at the end of the volume.Less
Twenty of the author's shorter pieces first published between 1963 and 2004 (when the book was initially prepared), which emphasize textual questions, verbal criticism, dramatic form and general interpretation. They are grouped roughly under the three words of the title, and handle subjects ranging from A: phenomena general to Greek Tragedy: its demand upon students and readers; stichomythia; the fragmentary tragedian Chaeremon; the attribution of a fragmentary Pirithous-play; the textual quality of quotations in Athenaeus; review of an important select edition of fragments; through (B): some topics particular to Euripides: scribal hands in a famous manuscript; the problematic Funeral Oration in Suppliants; that play's disputed date; appreciation of a choral ode in Hecuba; specialist lexicography of the poet; reviews of the now standard critical edition of the poet; to (C): appreciations of some scholars of Tragedy and particularly Euripides prominent since the 16th Century: Dirk Canter, Joshua Barnes, Jeremiah Markland, Samuel Musgrave, Peter Elmsley, James Henry Monk, and Frederick Apthorp Paley. All pieces have been edited, revised and supplemented with notes and bibliography as far as 2006. The problems of collecting and editing fragmentary texts emerge as the author's regular interest, anticipating his concentration on this work since 1995, in five collaborative editions and some shorter studies, some of which are listed or heralded in his List of Publications at the end of the volume.
