Thomas Schmidinger
- Published in print:
- 2020
- Published Online:
- January 2021
- ISBN:
- 9780197531365
- eISBN:
- 9780197554579
- Item type:
- chapter
- Publisher:
- Oxford University Press
- DOI:
- 10.1093/oso/9780197531365.003.0010
- Subject:
- Political Science, Middle Eastern Politics
When the so-called “Islamic State” (IS) attacked Iraq’s Nineveh Governorate, the region’s religious minorities became victims of genocide and displacement. This chapter focuses on the region of ...
More
When the so-called “Islamic State” (IS) attacked Iraq’s Nineveh Governorate, the region’s religious minorities became victims of genocide and displacement. This chapter focuses on the region of Sinjar (Kurdish: Şingal) and the displacement of the Yazidi (Kurdish: Êzîdî) along with other religious minorities living there. The displacement of these groups directly resulted from their vulnerability as religious minorities. IS targeted them as religious minorities, and their current problems as internally displaced persons (IDPs) also resulted from their status as relatively small communities without a historically strong political lobby or military force.
This chapter analyzes the living conditions and political framework in which these IDPs and refugees must survive and presents their personal perspectives from inside and outside of Iraq. Interviews were centered on the following questions: What conditions prevent Yazidi, Christians, and other groups from returning to Sinjar? What are their perspectives on building a future in the region? What would they need in order to return and rebuild their homes? And how
do the displaced adherents of the different religious groups interpret the 2014 genocide within a longer history of perceived genocidal acts against religious minorities in the area?Less
When the so-called “Islamic State” (IS) attacked Iraq’s Nineveh Governorate, the region’s religious minorities became victims of genocide and displacement. This chapter focuses on the region of Sinjar (Kurdish: Şingal) and the displacement of the Yazidi (Kurdish: Êzîdî) along with other religious minorities living there. The displacement of these groups directly resulted from their vulnerability as religious minorities. IS targeted them as religious minorities, and their current problems as internally displaced persons (IDPs) also resulted from their status as relatively small communities without a historically strong political lobby or military force.
This chapter analyzes the living conditions and political framework in which these IDPs and refugees must survive and presents their personal perspectives from inside and outside of Iraq. Interviews were centered on the following questions: What conditions prevent Yazidi, Christians, and other groups from returning to Sinjar? What are their perspectives on building a future in the region? What would they need in order to return and rebuild their homes? And how
do the displaced adherents of the different religious groups interpret the 2014 genocide within a longer history of perceived genocidal acts against religious minorities in the area?
Max Weiss
- Published in print:
- 2015
- Published Online:
- May 2016
- ISBN:
- 9780190458119
- eISBN:
- 9780190618520
- Item type:
- chapter
- Publisher:
- Oxford University Press
- DOI:
- 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190458119.003.0003
- Subject:
- Political Science, Middle Eastern Politics
Historians of the modern Middle East have long been concerned with the politics of identity, community and sect. The history of modern Syria remains bound up with the problematic of diversity and ...
More
Historians of the modern Middle East have long been concerned with the politics of identity, community and sect. The history of modern Syria remains bound up with the problematic of diversity and difference, most commonly explored in terms of minorities and sectarianism. In order to better understand struggles to describe, understand and master both categories and practices of minority and sect in the context of modern Syria, this chapter considers a variety of discourses on the Alawi community during the French Mandate and early independence periods. Scholarly discussion of sectarianism in modern Syria may run the risk of reifying sectarian identities, practices and modes of imagination. But this liability should not obviate the imperative to think through the significance of particular events, individuals or moments in modern Syrian history as well as to call into question nationalist, sectarianist, communitarian and other forms of historiographical, political and intellectual discourse that touch upon issues pertaining to the sectarian. The point of such critical analysis would be neither to uncritically reproduce earlier “mosaicist” or “sectarianist” approaches to the study of modern Syria — indeed, it is precisely such methodological lenses that have obfuscated some of the most interesting and complex historical realities there — nor simply to reduce Syrians to their ascriptive sectarian affiliations. One may hope that broader engagements with the genealogies of sectarianism in modern Syria may yet contribute to a more capacious and less conflictual understanding of Syrian difference and diversity.Less
Historians of the modern Middle East have long been concerned with the politics of identity, community and sect. The history of modern Syria remains bound up with the problematic of diversity and difference, most commonly explored in terms of minorities and sectarianism. In order to better understand struggles to describe, understand and master both categories and practices of minority and sect in the context of modern Syria, this chapter considers a variety of discourses on the Alawi community during the French Mandate and early independence periods. Scholarly discussion of sectarianism in modern Syria may run the risk of reifying sectarian identities, practices and modes of imagination. But this liability should not obviate the imperative to think through the significance of particular events, individuals or moments in modern Syrian history as well as to call into question nationalist, sectarianist, communitarian and other forms of historiographical, political and intellectual discourse that touch upon issues pertaining to the sectarian. The point of such critical analysis would be neither to uncritically reproduce earlier “mosaicist” or “sectarianist” approaches to the study of modern Syria — indeed, it is precisely such methodological lenses that have obfuscated some of the most interesting and complex historical realities there — nor simply to reduce Syrians to their ascriptive sectarian affiliations. One may hope that broader engagements with the genealogies of sectarianism in modern Syria may yet contribute to a more capacious and less conflictual understanding of Syrian difference and diversity.
Carool Kersten
- Published in print:
- 2016
- Published Online:
- October 2016
- ISBN:
- 9780190247775
- eISBN:
- 9780190638528
- Item type:
- book
- Publisher:
- Oxford University Press
- DOI:
- 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190247775.001.0001
- Subject:
- Religion, Islam
Islam in Indonesia maps the debates between progressive and reactionary Muslims in Indonesia since the regime change of 1998 and the start of a democratization process in the world’s largest Muslim ...
More
Islam in Indonesia maps the debates between progressive and reactionary Muslims in Indonesia since the regime change of 1998 and the start of a democratization process in the world’s largest Muslim nation state. Conceived as an intellectual history or history of ideas, this book situates these debates in Indonesia’s political context of the last fifteen years; it identifies and charts the genealogies of the different interlocutors; individual intellectuals and activists, institutions and outlets, which shape the discursive formations articulating the issues at hand. Organized around the concepts of secularism, pluralism and liberalism which were condemned in a fatwa issued by the Council of Indonesian Islamic Scholars in 2005, the discussion revolves around debates on Islamic statehood, Democracy, Islamic law, freedom of religion, religious minorities and human rights. It highlights the creative adaptation to the Indonesian situation of ideas originating in the Arabic-speaking parts of the Muslim world and in Western thought. These ideas have received far less scholarly attention than reactionary Islamism, Islamic extremism and violent political Islam. As alternatives to the ideologically loaded terms secularism, pluralism and liberalism, the book’s conclusion offers secularity, toleration, liberty and freethinking as more accurate alternatives.Less
Islam in Indonesia maps the debates between progressive and reactionary Muslims in Indonesia since the regime change of 1998 and the start of a democratization process in the world’s largest Muslim nation state. Conceived as an intellectual history or history of ideas, this book situates these debates in Indonesia’s political context of the last fifteen years; it identifies and charts the genealogies of the different interlocutors; individual intellectuals and activists, institutions and outlets, which shape the discursive formations articulating the issues at hand. Organized around the concepts of secularism, pluralism and liberalism which were condemned in a fatwa issued by the Council of Indonesian Islamic Scholars in 2005, the discussion revolves around debates on Islamic statehood, Democracy, Islamic law, freedom of religion, religious minorities and human rights. It highlights the creative adaptation to the Indonesian situation of ideas originating in the Arabic-speaking parts of the Muslim world and in Western thought. These ideas have received far less scholarly attention than reactionary Islamism, Islamic extremism and violent political Islam. As alternatives to the ideologically loaded terms secularism, pluralism and liberalism, the book’s conclusion offers secularity, toleration, liberty and freethinking as more accurate alternatives.
Michael Kerr and Craig Larkin (eds)
- Published in print:
- 2015
- Published Online:
- May 2016
- ISBN:
- 9780190458119
- eISBN:
- 9780190618520
- Item type:
- book
- Publisher:
- Oxford University Press
- DOI:
- 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190458119.001.0001
- Subject:
- Political Science, Middle Eastern Politics
Throughout the turbulent history of the Levant the Alawis — a secretive, resilient and ancient Muslim sect — have aroused suspicion and animosity, including accusations of religious heresy. More ...
More
Throughout the turbulent history of the Levant the Alawis — a secretive, resilient and ancient Muslim sect — have aroused suspicion and animosity, including accusations of religious heresy. More recently they have been tarred with the brush of political separatism and complicity in the excesses of the Assad regime, claims that have gained greater traction since the onset of the Syrian uprising and subsequent devastating civil war. The contributors to this book provide a complex and nuanced reading of Syria's Alawi communities — from loyalist gangs (Shabiha) to outspoken critics of the regime. Drawing upon wide-ranging research that examines the historic, political and social dynamics of the Alawi and the Syrian state, the current tensions are scrutinized and fresh insights offered. Among the themes addressed are religious practice, social identities, and relations to the Ba’ath party, the Syrian state and the military apparatus. The analysis also extends to Lebanon with a focus on the embattled Alawi community of Jabal Mohsen in Tripoli and state relations with Hizballah amid the current crisis.Less
Throughout the turbulent history of the Levant the Alawis — a secretive, resilient and ancient Muslim sect — have aroused suspicion and animosity, including accusations of religious heresy. More recently they have been tarred with the brush of political separatism and complicity in the excesses of the Assad regime, claims that have gained greater traction since the onset of the Syrian uprising and subsequent devastating civil war. The contributors to this book provide a complex and nuanced reading of Syria's Alawi communities — from loyalist gangs (Shabiha) to outspoken critics of the regime. Drawing upon wide-ranging research that examines the historic, political and social dynamics of the Alawi and the Syrian state, the current tensions are scrutinized and fresh insights offered. Among the themes addressed are religious practice, social identities, and relations to the Ba’ath party, the Syrian state and the military apparatus. The analysis also extends to Lebanon with a focus on the embattled Alawi community of Jabal Mohsen in Tripoli and state relations with Hizballah amid the current crisis.